List Search

31 N Main St
East Hampton, NY 11937 Outlying Eastern Suffolk


Hotel For Sale  •  6,250 Sq Ft

Property Details

  • Property Type Hotel
  • Total Building Size 6,250 Sq Ft
  • Lot Size 0.54 ac
  • Building Class B
  • Year Built 1790
  • Zoning pre-existing non-conformi
28 Transit Score
58 Walk Score


Situated across the street from East Hampton's iconic Old Hook Mill Windmill, the structures on these two contiguous parcels are part of the renewed Mill House Inn bed and breakfast. Each property has its own C/O, and they are zoned residential pre-existing non-conforming use in historic district. The property encompasses .54+/- acre with 6,250+/- sq. ft. of living space plus 1,800+/- sq. ft. in an unfinished basement. Built in 1790, major renovations were done in 1890, 1996, 2005 and 2011, with all windows new or historic restorations, in addition to new stone and glass bathrooms and a new chef's kitchen. There are 16 bedrooms, 10 bathrooms, four suites and four guest rooms, six gas and electric fireplaces. There are four zones of heat/AC, central air, and 600 amp electric service. Outdoors are 10 parking spaces.


two contiguous parcels
16 bedrooms
10 bathrooms
six gas and electric fireplaces
Hardwood Flooring


  • Air Conditioning
  • Concierge
  • Dishwasher
  • Fireplace
  • Laundry Facilities
  • Breakfast/Coffee Concierge
  • Kitchen
  • Community-Wide WiFi
  • Multi Use Room
  • Flat Screen TVs

Public Transportation

Commuter RailDriveWalkDistance
East Hampton Station Commuter Rail (Montauk Branch) 2 min 13 min 0.6 mi
Amagansett Station Commuter Rail (Montauk Branch) 5 min - 3.1 mi

Parking Details

Parking Available: Yes
Reserved: No
Spaces Provided: 10
Type: Surface
Included in Rent: Yes
Lee Minetree 516-729-7963 Saunders & Associates
Lee Minetree 516-729-7963 Saunders & Associates