List Search

74-A Montauk Hwy
East Hampton, NY 11937 Outlying Eastern Suffolk

Rate Upon Request

Restaurant For Lease  •  2,830 SF

Property Details

  • Property Type Restaurant
  • Year Built 1960
  • Total Building Size 2,830 SF
  • Tenancy Multiple
  • Building Class C
30 Transit Score
30 Walk Score

1 Space Available

Name Space Use Size Rent Details
1st Floor Ste Retail 2,830 SF Rate Upon Request
Located South of the Highway in Amagansett, this former diner features over 100 seats with indoor and outdoor seating. Spacious bar with open patio seating. New kitchen equipment and mechanicals. Office. Full basement with legal prep area - perfect for catering. Multiple walk-ins. Everything is in pristine condition. 31 Parking spots. Turnkey ... just bring your recipes!

$240,000 plus triple net fees for year-round (taxes $13,919)
$175,000 for May 22, 2026 to Sept. 15, 2026
$600,000 key-money 

Seasonal Rental
Year-Round	$240,00Apr 1st 2026 - Mar 31st 2027	Available
MD-LD	$175,000	May 22nd - Sep 7th 2026	Available

  • Date available: Now
  • Lease term: Negotiable
  • Service type: To Be Determined
  • Built out as: Restaurants And Cafes
  • Space Type: Relet

Public Transportation

Commuter RailDriveWalkDistance
Amagansett Station (Montauk Branch - Long Island Rail Road) 3 min 18 min 0.9 mi
East Hampton Station (Montauk Branch - Long Island Rail Road) 6 min - 2.6 mi
Transit/SubwayDriveWalkDistance
Amagansett Station (Montauk Branch - Long Island Rail Road) 2 min 18 min 0.9 mi

Parking Details

Parking Available: Yes
Reserved: No
Spaces Provided: 31
Type: Surface
Included in Rent: Yes
Lee Minetree 516-729-7963 Saunders & Associates
Lee Minetree 516-729-7963 Saunders & Associates