Back

1 of 16

2 of 16

3 of 16

4 of 16

5 of 16

6 of 16

7 of 16

8 of 16

9 of 16

10 of 16

11 of 16

12 of 16

13 of 16

14 of 16

15 of 16

16 of 16

533-605 Montauk Hwy
Bay Shore, NY 11706 Downtown Bay Shore

$4,350 - $4,375 USD/MO

Unknown For Lease • 1,500+ SF

Property Details

Property Type Unknown
Year Built 1951
Total Building Size 115,689 SF

0 Transit Score

75 Walk Score

2 Spaces Available

Name	Space Use	Size	Rent
1st Floor Ste 12	Retail	1,500 SF	$35.00 USD/SF/YR
Available January 2026! Elevate your brand in this high-visibility 1,500 SF retail space, available January 2026! Currently home to AT&T, this well-positioned storefront boasts excellent signage opportunities on both the façade and prominent pylon—perfect for grabbing attention. Located next to Supercuts and Jersey Mike’s, this space benefits from strong foot traffic and built-in co-tenancy appeal. Inside, enjoy modern comforts with AC, heating, and private restrooms already in place. Whether you're launching a new concept or expanding your footprint, this turnkey spot is the perfect next move. Don’t miss your chance to claim a proven retail location in a bustling center! Date available: Jan 2026 Lease term: Negotiable Service type: Triple Net Space Type: Relet
1st Floor Ste 20	Retail	1,800 SF	$29.00 USD/SF/YR
A ground-floor, end cap retail space with excellent window visibility and ample parking a few feet away. Space has 1,800 sqft available with A/C, central heating, and private restrooms. The previous tenant operated a Huntington Learning Center in this space. Located adjacent to a Miracle Ear. Date available: Now Lease term: Negotiable Service type: Triple Net Space Type: Relet

Description

· Bay Shore Commons is a grocery-anchored shopping center with 24 stores and over 109,000 square feet GLA. Fronting the highly traveled Montauk Highway, the center is one of the dominant retail destinations in Islip and Suffolk County, NY. There are more than 233,000 living within a 5-mile radius of the center. National and regional tenants in the center include Stop & Shop, Retro Fitness, Bagel Boss, Tropical Smoothie, Club Pilates, Hand & Stone Spa, Chase, Dunkin Donuts, and European Wax Center. The property is professionally managed and maintained by a team with over 85 years of experience.

                
                    Highlights
                
                                Heavy daytime foot traffic
                            
                                Property is professionally maintained and managed
                            
                                Within minutes from the Sunrise Highway
                            
                                Large Pylon

Property Flyers

Brochure

Amenities

24 Hour Access
Corner Lot
Pylon Sign
Signage
Signalized Intersection
Tenant Controlled HVAC
Kiosk/Cart Space

Major Tenants

Tenant	SF Occupied	Lease End Date
Chase Bank	4,000 SF
Club Pilates
Dunkin Donuts	500 SF
European Wax Center	1,500 SF
Hand and Stone Spa	2,000 SF	11/1/2026
Stop & Shop	47,810 SF
Supercuts	1,500 SF
Tropical Smoothie Cafe	1,400 SF	3/2/2012

Public Transportation

Commuter Rail	Drive	Walk	Distance
Islip Station (Montauk Branch - Long Island Rail Road)	3 min	-	1.3 mi
Bay Shore Station (Montauk Branch - Long Island Rail Road)	3 min	-	1.6 mi
Airport	Drive	Walk	Distance
Long Island MacArthur	19 min	-	10.5 mi
John F Kennedy International	47 min	-	34.0 mi

Taylor Uston 516-869-1240 Milbrook Properties Ltd.

533-605 Montauk Hwy Bay Shore, NY 11706 Downtown Bay Shore