List Search

4774 Mahoning Ave
Youngstown, OH 44515 North Outer Austintown/Boardman

Price Upon Request

Storefront For Sale  •  8,446 SF

Property Details

  • Property Type Storefront
  • Total Building Size 8,446 SF
  • Lot Size 0.85 AC
  • Building Class B
  • Year Built 2004
  • Tenancy Multiple
  • Zoning B-2
0 Transit Score
52 Walk Score

Highlights

NNN, 80% Occupied, Multi-Tenant NNN Center with Significant Upside Through Lease Up of Last Vacant Unit | Corner Location with Signalized Entrance
Successful Tenancy Consistently Exercising Renewals: Subway & Little Caesar’s Pizza Have Been In Place for Over 20 Years & 17 Years, Respectively
Newly Executed Long-Term 10-Year Lease for 2 Spaces, Further Enhancing Rent Roll Stability
Small Price Point with Over $425,000 of Upside Achievable Based on 7.75% CAP and Lease-Up of Just One Vacant Unit
Strong Demos in One of Youngstown’s Most Desirable Suburbs: Incomes Over $77k Within 5-Mile and High Population Density of 273k+ Residents in 10 Miles

Financial Summary (Actual)

Net Operating Income: $116,173 USD (2025)

Major Tenants

Tenant SF Occupied Lease End Date
Cricket 1,564 SF
Little Caesars 1,450 SF 7/1/2034
Subway 1,462 SF 4/1/2029
Vacant Unit 1,775 SF
Wild Bills Tobacco 2,232 SF 8/1/2035

Amenities

  • Corner Lot
  • Dedicated Turn Lane
  • Pylon Sign
  • Security System
  • Signage
  • Signalized Intersection
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Air Conditioning

Parking Details

Parking Available: Yes
Reserved: No
Spaces Provided: 55
Type: Surface
Included in Rent: Yes