Located in the heart of Oyster Bay’s historic downtown waterfront, 101 Audrey Avenue offers 4,437 square feet of prime retail space in one of Long Island’s most charming and economically vibrant communities. This rare opportunity allows tenants to occupy the former 20th Century Cycles building, famously home to famed singer-songwriter Billy Joel’s private motorcycle collection for the past 15 years. The property features an open-concept layout with polished concrete floors capable of supporting heavy display loads, high ceilings, wide column spacing, and a distinctive façade that reflects its unique history. Architectural elements such as exposed rafters, original beams, and skylights add character and charm, making it ideal for luxury retail, experiential showrooms, indoor recreation, galleries, or modern office concepts.
The building offers 44 feet of prominent frontage on Audrey Avenue, providing excellent visibility and exposure to over 4,000 vehicles per day, along with consistent daytime and evening foot traffic. Tenants benefit from amenities including air conditioning, tenant-controlled HVAC, skylights, wheelchair accessibility, and an on-site property manager. Located between Shore and Maxwell Avenue, the property is surrounded by boutiques, shops, and dining establishments, and is just a short walk from the Oyster Bay Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) station and Theodore Roosevelt Park & Marina.
Oyster Bay Village is bordered by affluent communities such as Oyster Bay Cove, East Norwich, Upper Brookville, and Mill Neck. The area boasts a population of 73,463 within a 5-mile radius, with $1.2 billion in consumer spending in 2024 and an average household income of $172,000. The workforce is highly educated, with 57% of residents holding college degrees. The location also benefits from proximity to major airports, including LaGuardia, JFK, and Westchester County Airport, making it accessible to both local and regional visitors.
Long Island continues to thrive economically, contributing nearly 12% of New York State’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP), second only to New York City. Nassau County’s proximity to the city and access to public transportation make it a highly desirable location for retailers and professionals alike. This property presents a unique chance to establish a presence in a landmark location with strong tourism, affluent demographics, and a vibrant downtown atmosphere.
Tanya Espinal
Renaissance Property Associates
